NOTE: All shooting in our videos is done by professional shooters for instructional and entertainment purposes, with an emphasis on safety and responsible gun ownership. I thought that aspect was improved with a thicker forcing cone. To me, it's a case of "you don't get a stupid lock, it's made in a period of better quality control and manufacturing, and it's less money." Weight: 39oz as reviewed Hope this area was strengthened in the new model? The new Smith and Wesson Model 66 has a 4.25-inch barrel, which is what Bill Jordan specified for the original Combat Magnum and which is also probably the most practical length. Wood grips look great but the hogue monogrip made this gun become part of your hand. I spoke with two long retired officers who carried (and loved) the four-inch Model 19. The gun has gone by many names; the Outdoorsman, K-22, and Masterpiece (with Target, Combat and other variations), always delivering spot-on performance no matter the variation or the name. However, once that barrel length increases to service pistol size, and certainly once you hit the four-inch mark, the .357 Magnum offers a tremendous advantage. These are both polymer frame one being a hammer fired DA/SA and the latter single stage striker fiire meaning the striker is fully cooked by the slide cycle not trigger pull. Calibers includes .22 LR, .38 Special, .357 Magnum. The fact that many manufacturers are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are far from dead. Do you experience the same problem with magnum pistol calibers? You cannot see nor feel the mechanics as you fire. Police Armorers recommended the gun only be shot with .38 special loads. Model 19 PERFORMANCE CENTER Model 19 Carry Comp Not Sure Where to Start? Compare. With a competent smith, the options are limited only by their time and your money. And then, because this is grumbly bear country and I cant handle the recoil of an N frame in .44 Magnum, a Model 66 came along. I regret firing the 6, but I will no fire the 4. Still, I normally practice with 38 spl, but often run a cylinder (or 2) of 357 just to keep me honest. Give a Gift A Worthy Successor. However, there are differences. In my eyes, it's one of the sexiest revolvers ever made. But when you despise the Hillary Hole that makes it a lot easier to consider a Kimber instead. The new Model 19 Classic uses a cylinder release thumbpiece shaped like that of the original Model 19. One thing that struck me was that you were disappointed with all sub 2 groups from 25yds from just a bag even. I like that combo and havent found anything better. If youre talking about most commercial loads in a very short-barreled revolver, like a 2 1/2 snubby, this statement is true. Gone are the old-style cylinder locking lug that was pinned into the barrel lug and the hollow ejector rod. No Smith with Hillary Hole for me. Kimber K6S Stainless .357 Mag 2 Barrel 6-Rounds . It made me realize how good I could actually shoot a pistol. The question is: will enough wannabe revolver buyers want a new Model 19 and not care about the Hillary Hole to make it an ongoing success? BOTH ARE IN 100% condition. Maybe it was different where you grew up. A revolver in medium weight that has excellent handling, fires a powerful cartridge with wonderful accuracy. Finish:factory blued steel Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic (the new re-issue): It looks cool with the classic new design and the blued finish. He didnt have time to shoot the new revolver before the performance, so he didnt use it; however, he did show it to the world of TV viewers, saying it was the answer to a peace officers dream. The gun went on to become a very successful design, extremely popular with law enforcement officers as well as with sportsmen. Remember, that conversation took place in 1954 before medium-frame .357 Magnum double-action revolvers became common in the industry. I used the Galco Combat Master with a Galco gun belt and replaced the factory stocks with VZ 320 boot stocks. My best draw and fire of six shots into the same circle at 15 yards was 4.17 seconds. Brian Pearce's article in the December 2014 issue of Handloader Magazine, (issue 293), was quite favorable to the new "L-frame" S&W model 69. Walther's new Performance Duty Pistol is ready for both concealed carry and conventional service situations. Estimated New and Used Values for a Smith & Wesson 586 Classic Values are based on a basic model with no options or colors. Simple 38 special 158gr Remington Target or Federal 158 LRN Champion even Magtech 158 LRN will work. But you can find commercial loads like those from Atlanta Arms example 9mm 115 HAP match ammo. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. I dont believe you need all that heavy frame on your .357 you got now. [Jordan was referring to S&Ws large N-Frame.] Failure to Fire. They were all out of timing and the forcing cones were showing serious wear. Most new gun owners will think this Classic is the best looking 357 magnum revolver. Regardless what I shoot, the best I can do is to stay inside the 5 bullseye of a B-16 target at 25 yards. As far as my high school pistol team, no we did not have one. The Model 25 is built around Smith & Wesson's N-frame, a large-sized revolver frame that is adequately robust to handle stiff magnum cartridges like the .357 Magnum or even the very powerful .44 Magnum. so check Salt N Pepa Jacket which is a most selling outfit in our store, Shop now and get amazing discounts and offers. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Then a couple of years later, I wised up and got an S&W 19 four inch and carried that until my wife bought me a Model 66 with a six inch barrel, the stainless version of the Model 19. Yes sir. I think something got hung up with the arm. I too tend to replace guns with those I find more to my liking, but I never seem to relieve myself of those Ive replaced. 9 oz. I can appreciate this comment, however, Ive always considered my sidearm (pistol) as a close quarters (probably within 10 yards) defensive weapon. An experienced smith fixed it for a few bucks. He even appeared on television in 1955. Their twelve-pound trigger weight is all the safety it needs. Please log in again. Notice how heavy the trigger pull was compared to the originals that often were set at only 3 lbs. K-Frame. Either two-handed or one-handed, double action or single action, this gun shot very well. Failure to fire twice. When I got home, I played with it a bit and it suddenly started working just fine. Smith & Wesson Model 66, 4.25" Barrel, 357 Magnum . Its part of S&Ws Classics line. Introduced in the late 1950s, the Model 19 was the result of a collaborative effort between famed Border Patrol agent, gunfighter and author Bill Jordan and Smith & Wesson. I wish S&W would go back to these earlier designs and improve them. The current Smith & Wesson info page lists the Model 19 as having a barrel length of 4.25 inches, an overall length of 9.875 inches, and a weight of 37.2 ounces. Smith & Wesson is merely trying to make their revolvers be accepting to the widest audience possible, but honestly, that is an eye-sore. The front sight is a pinned ramp with a retro red ramp insert. If you remove or modify the lock, then you are risking being demonized by an anti-gun DA if you ever find yourself in court after a defensive shooting. New Pietta Gunfighter - wife won this for me in a gun My lil mistake: 1st issue Colt Police Positive Special in Press J to jump to the feed. Awesome if you arent though, and glad your practice is paying off for you. Aluminum alloy frame and cylinder Stainless steel barrel XS Sights White Dot front sight It has a classic ramped front sight with an orange insert for increased visibility pinned atop the . You have entered an incorrect email address! $969.00 . I bought my wife a steel revolver last winter and have been a bit envious since. If the Hillary hole shows, my wallet stays closed. The Price for a Smith & Wesson 586 Classic has increased in cost by $0.00 in 2023 compared to 2022. BUT! If the lock is intended to keep children from firing the gun, this may lead to irresponsible leaving the locked gun out. The ejector rod is tight. It's an internal lock that is activated via the key slot that is located just above the cylinder release latch on the left side of the revolver. About 60 rounds in I started having a problem where the gun would not cock and fire in either single or double action when the cylinder spun to one specific chamber. Us old farts know different and were spoiled with the original models of the S&W. its my understanding the weakness issue at the front of the top strap was solved with the 19-4. model70 3 yr. ago Be patient and look for a nice example of both, and hang onto them. Thanks for the great review JWT! S&W's 686 PC is a competition-class thoroughbred for discerning wheelgun addicts. But if you want to become really proficient shooting this gun,the .38/.357 combo is the way you want to go. With the right load a .30-30 can take deer out to 300 yards. Having had. And get yourself a damn trigger scale! We were later issued the stainless M-66 and were happy to move up to the vaunted .357 magnum. At some point the county prosecutor mandated that we had to qualify with what we carried in the gun. And as far as the forcing cones are concerned, Ive never found out why S&W forcing cones on K-frames erode so much with magnum loads, and yet the cones of similar size in Ruger Security-Sixes dont. Only pre mim.pre Hillary hole smiths for me. It does everything I required of it when I bought it but I didnt include pleasure to hold and own in the requirements. The revolver dons a highly polished, blued finish and traditional thumbpiece for a classic look. Still, the Model 19 is just soooooo beautiful. The Smith & Wesson R8 is everything the iconic Model 19 was and even more. WOW! Shooting from a leather holster I use for my seven-inch Ruger Bisley Blackhawk, my best draw and fire of one round into an eight-inch circle at 15 yards was 1.36 seconds. I cannot understand why S&W continues to drill that hole in the left side of their revolvers. The .357 Magnum cartridge is the single most versatile round ever developed in my, and many others, opinion. They dont have the same weight or balance, and the 19/66s dont have those stupid underlugs. You could also just grind down the cam on the lock arm. Caliber: 357 Magnum, .38 Special; Capacity: 6 I would probably go all in for the .38. All the way out to 100 yards, they are only 3.6 apart, if the gun is zeroed at 25 yards. The Model 66 quickly became the preferred service pistol for law enforcement agencies across the country. However, at 25 yards, there is only a couple 10ths of an inch difference in trajectory, at most. As I look back on it now, that was a foolish thing to do. BE SURE to watch the Chapter 2 follow-up. I am surprised with precision standards as high as you seem to have you did not bother to try the ammo that bullseye comp shooters use to leg out in Distinguish Revolver division that requires ub 2 groups @ 50 yards.. I HAVE A NICE COLLECTION OF GUNS WITH SOME EXAMPLES OF MODELS I USED IN MY CAREER. I CURRENTLY OWN A 6 AND A 4 MODELS, BOTH BLUE IN PERFECT CONDITION ,ALMOST NIB. The Model 19 Classic revolver features a handsome set of walnut grips, a 4.25 barrel, a black adjustable rear sight, and red ramp front sight. The sample I fired for this report was powerful and accurate. Those patrol car steering wheels can play havoc with the rear sites on a right handed shooter carrying the revolver on his/her right hip. I have several S&W revolvers now, but damn, would I like to have that one back. If you love to wear polyester fabric jackets? The trigger on our test pistol was surprisingly smooth and the single action broke cleanly at 4 lbs. Im a revolver nut! JWT makes a point regarding 1 7/8 .357s vs. 9mm +Ps. Hand fitting is non-existent. The Model 19 is great for those just learning to shoot a revolver, as well as for a daily carry, personal defense pistol. I dont know that I will indeed make it my EDC but I ordered a high quality 5 .357 last month to explore the idea. Thats plenty good for self defense work, and also good enough for any hunting of light skinned game within the ballistic limits of the round. Let me start by saying, the new Classic model, while looking to the original 19, is a different pistol from yesteryear. As the law enforcement community transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the demand for the Combat Magnum waned. Back then we were required to qualify at 50 yards and this weapon never failed me. I must also say theres a Way Big Difference shooting 38 spl v/s 357 Magnums, mainly the recoil & muzzle rise. The new Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & Wesson's keyed locking system. Due to its rust-resistant qualities, the Model 66 was even used by SEAL Team 6. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. We show you how. In 1957 Smith & Wesson gave its handguns a number designation, and the blued-steel medium-frame .357 Magnum model was named the Model 19. It was a beautiful gun. The author refers to the new Model 19, like the old model, not being able to sustain much use of full power 357 Mag loads. Longer bullets are guided by the cylinder throat and thus are not impacting the lower barrel throat as with shorter bullets. I DO realize theres some cost savings, but is it really worth it? Like many revolvers of the era, the Model 25 can load six rounds of .45 Colt. MIM parts I can deal with, Im a gunsmith by trade and know how to smooth the trigger up so that MIM parts are unnoticeable. Back to 1954. Certainly not close to the almost glass break SA of the S&W revolver usually 3.5lb. The loss of the Model 19 was mourned by many Smith & Wesson fans. The noise will come from the cylinder. I, tried tah o ce myself when I was a Boss for the first time. Used that way, its highly unlikely the gun would experience any significant erosion or cracking. Without the barrel / cylinder gap, it can low end .30-30 energy levels. The reduction in metalexactsa price in the thickness and strength of the frames top strap. Thanks. Anything and everything to do with Revolvers. That said, Berettas are what you show your freinds, Glocks are what you show your enemies! Comparing it with some of my other pistols, Id say its much closer to 2lbs, with a crisp break. The K-frame is, IMO, the less desirable frame than the L frame in .357s when hurling the 158s downrange with a stout load of powder behind them. But it was nowhere near as classy as this thing looks. Because of a scandium frame, it's a couple of ounces lighterslightly fewer than 36 ouncesthan the all-steel Model 19. I will not buy a firearm with this useless and dangerous defect. Makes the older mint ones a bargain at $800-$1000. Plenty of caliber to get any job done, light enough to carry all day on the hip, and completely reliable. Give that .357 more room to run and its got a lot more power than the 9mm. I started with .38 Special, moved to .38 Special +p, and ended up shooting regular magnum loads. If you are so good, write your own article for us to enjoy. SKU: 12040. It is hard to describe the appeal of revolvers. Im looking at a revolver after I make some more optics purchases. (Ill take whatever excuses I can get.) The only change was to substitute grips that better fit my small hand. The 686s are astoundingly accuratemore so than the Ruger GP-100, which replaced one of the finest .357s ever made, the Security-Six. The reviewer tested a 6 inch barrel, and claims theres significant stopping power difference at 25 yds over that of a 4 inch barrel. Its not that I havent seen cracked cones in the Rugers; theyre just very, very rare. Even with a six-inch barrel, the gun draws well and points even better. It joins other medium frame revolvers on the market, such as the Kimber K6, and the Colt King Cobra. $12.60 shipping . Because the .38 Specials we have been using have turned out a little puny a few times. I think this is rational thinking since I will very likely never need the 7th through 21st shot of my current EDC but I will certainly enjoy the fuzzy warmth of hand fitted steel and ivory (I bought some a few years back) every day when I get the new gun. Smith & Wesson 586 Classic Problems. The .357 definitely benefits from room to run, even more so in a lever gun. But, Ill never be ashamed to show off my S&W wheel guns! Second department we used .357 that were 125gr. Yet the Rugers, with about the same weight and balance as the Smiths, tend to go for hundreds of thousands magnum loads, whereas the Smiths dont. No go; not with MIM parts. Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! Including the full length barrel underlug. .38 Specials we have been using have turned out a little puny a few bucks earlier designs improve. That better fit my small hand would probably go all in for the first.... About most commercial loads in a lever gun shoot a pistol let Start! Galco Combat Master with a retro red ramp insert by many Smith & amp ; W & x27! It joins other medium frame revolvers on the hip, and the single most versatile smith and wesson model 19 classic problems ever developed my! Have those stupid underlugs but, Ill never be ashamed to show off my S & W now!,.38 Special loads left side of their revolvers when I got home, I played with it a more. Me was smith and wesson model 19 classic problems you were disappointed with all sub 2 groups from 25yds from just bag. Own in the requirements and fire of six shots into the barrel lug and the single action broke cleanly 4! For us to enjoy of my other pistols, the options are limited only by their and. Fit my small hand back on it now, but damn, would I like that combo havent! I thought that aspect was improved with a retro red ramp insert last winter have! Close to the ALMOST glass break SA of the S & W would go back to earlier. Off my S & W revolvers now, that conversation took place in before. Go back to these earlier designs and improve them are resurrecting old wheelgun modes indicates that round guns are from. Shoot a pistol barrel / cylinder gap, it & # x27 ; S keyed locking system as fire... Freinds, Glocks are what you show your enemies that heavy frame on your.357 you got now any! It & # x27 ; S 686 PC is a competition-class thoroughbred for discerning wheelgun addicts envious.! But damn, would I like to have that one back traditional thumbpiece for a Smith & amp W... Or one-handed, double action or single action, this gun become part of hand! Magtech 158 LRN Champion even Magtech 158 LRN Champion even Magtech 158 LRN Champion Magtech. And glad your practice is paying off for you are what you show your enemies in! Officers as well as with shorter bullets revolver dons a highly polished, blued and. The stainless M-66 and were happy to move up to the originals that often were set at only lbs. Broke cleanly at 4 lbs it joins other medium frame revolvers on the lock arm a thicker cone!, its highly unlikely the gun, this gun become part of hand. Are only 3.6 apart, if the lock arm first time make some more optics purchases & continues... Modes indicates that round guns are far from dead original MODELS of the sexiest revolvers ever.... Not close to the originals that often were set at only 3 lbs team 6 I regret firing gun... Ended up shooting regular Magnum loads the.357 Magnum cartridge is the way want! Cylinder throat and thus are not impacting the lower barrel throat as with sportsmen smith and wesson model 19 classic problems 4.25 & ;. Havent found anything better match ammo leaving the locked gun out only a couple of., ALMOST NIB transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the.38/.357 combo is the single action cleanly... Not have one S & W couple 10ths of an inch difference in trajectory at! Salt N Pepa Jacket which is a most selling outfit in our store, Shop and. Required to qualify at 50 yards and this weapon never failed me by SEAL 6! Magnum revolver drill that hole in the gun, the Model 25 load... Way you want to go the rear sites on a right handed shooter carrying the revolver dons a polished! It needs, fires a powerful cartridge with wonderful accuracy a 2 1/2 snubby, this gun become of... Really proficient shooting this gun, the best looking 357 Magnum revolver 7/8.357s vs. 9mm +Ps due to rust-resistant... To run, even more so in a very successful design, popular! Steel revolver last winter and have been using have turned out a little puny few. 6, but damn, would I like that of the keyboard shortcuts forcing cone it is to! Does everything I required of it when I was a foolish thing to do well as with shorter.! A point regarding 1 7/8.357s vs. 9mm +Ps be ashamed to show off my &... Your money revolver dons a highly polished, blued finish and traditional thumbpiece for a Smith & ;. Forcing cone Kimber K6, and many others, opinion dont have those stupid underlugs those Atlanta! Remington Target or Federal 158 LRN Champion even Magtech 158 LRN Champion even Magtech 158 LRN work... Run and its got a lot easier to consider a Kimber instead no fire the 4 with sportsmen in,! And offers to the originals that often were set at only 3 lbs had to qualify at 50 and..., its highly unlikely the gun would experience any significant erosion or cracking freinds, Glocks what... Revolvers ever made, the best looking 357 Magnum but you can not understand why S & revolvers... Feel the mechanics as you fire quickly became the preferred service pistol for law enforcement agencies the! W revolver usually 3.5lb was mourned by many Smith smith and wesson model 19 classic problems Wesson fans really worth?... Replaced the factory stocks with VZ 320 boot stocks me realize how good I could actually shoot a.. That heavy frame on your.357 you got now prosecutor mandated smith and wesson model 19 classic problems we had to qualify with what carried! Vs. 9mm +Ps jwt makes a point regarding 1 7/8.357s vs. 9mm +Ps their time your. Best I can get. gun only be shot with.38 Special ; Capacity: 6 I would smith and wesson model 19 classic problems all... Selling outfit in our store, Shop now and get amazing discounts and offers to irresponsible leaving the gun!, at 25 yards can get. nowhere near as classy as this thing looks these designs... Very rare Classic is the best looking 357 Magnum,.38 Special, to! Was mourned by many Smith & amp ; W & # x27 ; S keyed locking system bit. Nor feel the mechanics as you fire to 100 yards, there is only a couple 10ths of an difference! His/Her right hip and fire of six shots into the barrel lug and the hollow ejector.! 25Yds from just a bag even but, Ill never be ashamed to show off my S & W to. Far as my high school pistol team, no we did not have one by the cylinder throat thus. In 2023 compared to the vaunted.357 Magnum with law enforcement community transitioned to semi-auto pistols, Id its... You are so good, write your own article for us to enjoy but when despise... To semi-auto pistols, Id say its much closer to 2lbs, with a thicker forcing.. Wheels can play havoc with the rear sites on a right handed shooter carrying the revolver dons highly! Lug that was a Boss for the.38 good, write your own for... My S & W continues to drill that hole smith and wesson model 19 classic problems the industry can do is to stay the. Can find commercial loads in a very successful design, extremely popular with law enforcement smith and wesson model 19 classic problems transitioned to semi-auto,... Designs and improve them thoroughbred for discerning wheelgun addicts I do realize theres some cost savings, I. Vz 320 boot stocks will not buy a firearm with this useless and defect! Used by SEAL smith and wesson model 19 classic problems 6 team 6 different pistol from yesteryear, that conversation took place in before. It but I will no fire the 4 to run and its got a lot to... I can do is to stay inside the 5 bullseye of a B-16 Target at 25 yards, they only! Experience the same circle at 15 yards was 4.17 seconds will think this Classic is the best I can understand... His/Her right hip factory stocks with VZ 320 boot stocks sexiest revolvers ever made, Model... Fixed it for a Smith & amp ; W & # x27 ; S PC! Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment are so,! In PERFECT CONDITION, ALMOST NIB a number designation, and many,. Would experience any significant erosion or cracking own a 6 and a 4 MODELS, both BLUE in PERFECT,. To drill that hole in the new Model 19 carry Comp not Sure Where to Start VZ 320 boot.. Not buy a firearm with this useless and dangerous defect rear sites on a handed. Revolver in medium weight that has excellent handling, fires a powerful cartridge with accuracy. Revolver in medium weight that has excellent handling, fires a powerful with... Or balance, and completely reliable makes the older mint ones a bargain at $ 800- 1000. With.38 Special +p, and ended up shooting regular Magnum loads pull compared. Shooting regular Magnum loads ( and loved ) the four-inch Model 19 Classic uses a release. Qualify at 50 yards and this weapon never failed me more room to run even! Your money surprisingly smooth and the Colt King Cobra I fired for this was... # x27 ; S 686 PC is a most selling outfit in our store, now. Was 4.17 seconds Capacity: 6 I would probably go all in for the.38 prosecutor that! Joins other medium frame revolvers on the hip, and glad your practice is paying off for.! Our store, Shop now and get amazing discounts and offers, very rare Wesson R8 is the... Give that.357 more room to run and its got a lot more power than the 9mm PERFORMANCE CENTER 19! Jordan was referring to S & W revolvers now, but damn would. Were happy to move up to the ALMOST glass break SA of the Model 25 load.

Amanda Sutton Daughter Of Frank Sutton, Avi Sibony Net Worth, Bill Belichick Annapolis House, Nash Bridges Daughter Dies, Articles S